Toca Madera Scottsdale

7340 E Shoeman Ln, Scottsdale, AZ 85251 · tocamadera.com

Read Full Review →

Toca Madera earns the top spot because it does something most restaurants in Old Town Scottsdale can’t: it delivers on atmosphere, food, and service at the same time, every night. The kitchen runs on modern Mexican cooking built around high-quality, sustainable, and organic ingredients — but the food is only part of what makes a reservation here a distinct experience. Fire performers move through the room on weekend nights, a live DJ controls the energy from open to close, and the cocktail program consistently produces some of the most inventive drinks in the Valley. The flagship Ghost Rider margarita — served tableside with a burst of flame — has become one of the most photographed drinks in Scottsdale for good reason.

The menu covers the full spectrum of occasions: a dedicated taqueria menu for something more casual, a serious dinner menu for a proper night out, weekend brunch with bottomless options, and a happy hour that draws locals who know the value. Toca Madera also happens to be one of the most accommodating restaurants in the area for dietary restrictions — vegetarian, vegan, pescatarian, and gluten-free guests all eat well here, not as an afterthought. For a complete breakdown of everything the restaurant offers, read our full Toca Madera Scottsdale review. Make reservations well in advance, especially Thursday through Saturday.

FnB Restaurant

7125 E 5th Ave, Scottsdale, AZ 85251 · fnbrestaurant.com

FnB is the restaurant serious food people in Phoenix and Scottsdale talk about when they’re being honest. Chef Charleen Badman has received multiple James Beard Foundation nominations for Best Chef Southwest — not for novelty or spectacle, but for the kind of vegetable-forward cooking that proves you don’t need a centerpiece protein to build one of the most memorable plates you’ll eat all year. The menu changes constantly based on what Arizona farmers are producing, which means the dish you had in November won’t be there in March. That’s not a problem — it’s the whole point.

The Arizona wine list is exceptional and nearly unmatched in the state for its depth and regional focus. The room itself is small and intimate — around 60 seats — which means reservations are hard to come by on weekends. Book a month out for Friday and Saturday nights if you can. FnB sits on 5th Avenue, one of the quieter and more residential-feeling streets in Old Town, which gives it a neighborhood restaurant feel that most of the louder spots on Scottsdale Road can’t replicate. If you’re putting together a full evening in the area, check out our guide to the best things to do in Scottsdale before and after dinner.

Citizen Public House

7111 E 5th Ave #130, Scottsdale, AZ 85251 · citizenpublichouse.com

Citizen Public House occupies the exact category that Old Town Scottsdale genuinely needed more of: the serious gastropub that doesn’t take itself too seriously. The kitchen produces elevated American comfort food with a level of craft that would feel at home in a white-tablecloth room, but the vibe is relaxed enough that you can sit at the bar solo on a Tuesday and feel like a regular by the time you finish your second cocktail. The Original Chophouse Salad has become something of a local institution — a dish that locals send visitors here specifically to try.

The cocktail program is the bar’s real calling card. The team takes classic templates and applies genuinely interesting technique — house-made bitters, barrel-aged spirits, and rotating seasonal ingredients — without the pretension that sometimes comes with that approach. Happy hour is one of the most reliable in Old Town: weekdays from 3–6pm with half-price appetizers and well-priced cocktails that are actually worth ordering. Citizen is also the right choice when you want something great but aren’t ready to commit to the full Toca Madera production. Both are on 5th Avenue, practically a block apart — and after dinner at Citizen, the full Scottsdale restaurant scene is right outside the door.

Toca Madera Scottsdale holds the top spot for the overall experience — food quality, atmosphere, service, and cocktail program all operating at a high level simultaneously. For strictly food-focused dining, FnB Restaurant is arguably the most critically respected kitchen in Old Town and has been for years. The right answer depends on what you’re optimizing for: if it’s the full night-out experience with a group, Toca Madera. If it’s the most thoughtful cooking in the neighborhood, FnB.

For Thursday through Saturday evenings from October through April — yes, absolutely. Old Town’s best restaurants fill up fast during peak season, and showing up without a reservation on a Saturday night will usually mean a 45-minute to two-hour wait, if they can seat you at all. Toca Madera and FnB both take reservations through their websites and OpenTable. Citizen Public House has walk-in bar seating that’s genuinely accessible without a reservation, which makes it the best option if you need flexibility on a weekend night.

Fifth Avenue and the Scottsdale Waterfront are where the highest concentration of quality restaurants are clustered. Fifth Avenue has both FnB and Citizen Public House within a block of each other and feels more like a neighborhood dining street than a tourist corridor. The Scottsdale Waterfront along the Arizona Canal has excellent outdoor dining options with patio seating along the water. Scottsdale Road itself has plenty of options but skews toward higher-volume spots — the off-Scottsdale-Road streets are where the best cooking tends to happen. If you want to combine great restaurants with easy walking to the best things to do in Scottsdale, base yourself in the 5th Avenue and Scottsdale Waterfront area.

Old Town Scottsdale is genuinely one of the best bachelorette dinner destinations in the Southwest — and Toca Madera is the most requested restaurant for exactly that occasion. The combination of excellent food, fire performers, live music, craft cocktails, and an energy that builds as the night goes on makes it purpose-built for the format. Book a private dining section if you have a group of 10 or more. After dinner, the nightlife corridor in Old Town is close enough to walk to, which means the transition from dinner to the rest of the evening is seamless. The weather from October through April makes the whole experience even better.